DeltaMV

How Behavioural Economics Can Reduce Antibiotic Over-Prescription

By DeltaMV Insights TeamUpdated 7 min read

GPs already know that unnecessary antibiotics fuel resistance, yet over-prescription persists. Behavioural economics can reduce antibiotic over-prescription by making each GP’s prescribing visible and comparable: in Australia, peer-comparison letters cut scripts among high prescribers by 12.3% in six months – without a single new clinical guideline. This article explains why GPs over-prescribe, how peer comparison changes behaviour, what the evidence shows, and four steps health systems across Asia-Pacific can take to apply the same approach.

Key takeaways

  • In 2024, 37.1% of Australians had at least one antimicrobial dispensed in the community.
  • Many GPs assumed their prescribing was similar to their colleagues’ – peer-comparison letters showed it wasn’t.
  • Letters comparing GPs with their peers cut scripts by 12.3% among Australia’s top 30% of prescribers.
  • The same low-cost nudge can work anywhere with routine prescribing data, without new legislation or funding.

What Is Antibiotic Over-Prescription, and Why Does It Matter?

Antibiotic over-prescription is prescribing antibiotics when they aren’t needed – and every unnecessary script speeds the rise of antibiotic-resistant bacteria, so-called ‘superbugs’, and shortens the working life of the antibiotics we already rely on.

The scale of the problem in Australia is significant: in 2024, 37.1% of the population, more than ten million people, had at least one antimicrobial dispensed under the community pharmaceutical benefits scheme, and a meaningful share of that prescribing is thought to be unnecessary (Australian Centre for Disease Control, 2026).

Why Do GPs Over-Prescribe Antibiotics?

Facts alone are not the problem. GPs had long been aware of the public health risks of overprescribing antibiotics, but many assumed their own prescribing habits were much the same as their colleagues’.

That is why simply telling GPs to prescribe fewer antibiotics rarely works: most already know the clinical case against overprescribing. The barrier isn’t information, it’s behaviour – and in particular, a misjudgement of where one’s own prescribing sits compared with peers.

How Does Peer Comparison Change Prescribing Behaviour?

Peer comparison works through social comparison: showing GPs exactly how their scripts stack up against similar colleagues challenges the social norms around prescribing and makes them think twice before writing a script. Australia’s campaign took a multi-faceted approach, but central to it were letters comparing GPs’ prescribing with their peers’. This is often linked to the Hawthorne Effect – the idea that people behave differently when they feel they are being observed (Medical Republic, 2018). Three things make peer-comparison letters work.

1. They make the invisible visible

A GP can’t act on a gap between their own prescribing and their peers’ if they never see that gap, and a personalised letter makes it impossible to miss. When GPs began receiving these letters, many realised that what they’d assumed was ‘normal’ prescribing wasn’t normal at all.

2. They tap into professional identity

Being shown you prescribe more than similar GPs in your area challenges how you see yourself as a careful, competent practitioner – a far stronger motivator than a reminder about antimicrobial resistance in the abstract.

3. They use loss aversion

A GP is more troubled by learning they’re an outlier on the high side than they are motivated by praise for being average, which is why comparison, not congratulation, drives the effect. Learn more about loss aversion.

Does It Work? Evidence From Australia and the UK

Yes. Peer-reviewed data and a controlled trial both show meaningful reductions in antibiotic prescribing.

Case 1: NPS MedicineWise antimicrobial-resistance programmes (Australia)

  • Context: national antimicrobial-resistance programmes run by NPS MedicineWise since 2009, with a more intensive push from 2012.
  • Intervention: a multi-faceted campaign aimed at GPs.
  • Result: an average of 126,536 fewer antibiotics dispensed each month – a 14% overall reduction. Between August 2012 and June 2015, GPs dispensed roughly 184,442 fewer prescriptions a month than forecast, close to a 20% reduction (Wu et al., 2018).
  • Limitation: this is an analysis of national dispensing data, so the effect of each component of the campaign cannot be separated.
  • Lesson for practice: sustained, multi-year programmes can shift national prescribing.

Case 2: Peer-comparison letters (Australian Government Behavioural Economics Team)

  • Context: the country’s top 30% of antibiotic prescribers.
  • Intervention: a letter with a graph comparing each GP’s prescribing to their peers.
  • Result: GPs who received the letter cut their scripts by 12.3% over six months – more than three times the effect of educational material alone (Medical Republic, 2018).
  • Limitation: results are reported over six months; longer-term effects need ongoing monitoring.
  • Lesson for practice: comparison beats education – show GPs their position, don’t just restate the guidelines.

Case 3: The UK trial

  • Result: a comparable UK trial using the same approach achieved a smaller but still meaningful 3.3% reduction (World Health Organization, 2018).
  • Lesson for practice: the approach transfers across health systems, though the size of the effect varies.

Planning an antimicrobial stewardship programme? DeltaMV’s Healthcare Behavioural Strategy team can help you turn prescribing data into behaviour change.

How Can Health Systems in Asia-Pacific Apply This Approach?

Any health authority or payer in the region that works with large GP or pharmacist networks and routine prescribing data can use the same low-cost nudge, without waiting on new legislation or funding.

Antimicrobial resistance is one of the defining public health challenges facing the whole Asia-Pacific region, where high rates of community antibiotic use and variable stewardship infrastructure make resistant infections a growing risk. That’s why the World Health Organization featured Australia’s peer-comparison letters as a global case study during World Antibiotic Awareness Week (World Health Organization, 2018). Australia’s own antibiotic consumption – 23.5 defined daily doses per 1,000 population, against an OECD average of 20.6 – shows there’s still considerable room to improve even in a well-resourced health system.

The same mechanism has also worked elsewhere in the region: in Japan, a monthly peer-comparison newsletter cut unnecessary antibiotic prescriptions at a children’s emergency centre – see our article on how behavioural science helps reduce doctors’ over-testing.

4 Steps to Use Behavioural Economics to Reduce Antibiotic Over-Prescription

Be explicit about your goal – ‘I want GPs to prescribe fewer antibiotics’ – then make the desired behaviour visible, emotionally tangible and simple.

  1. Start with prescribing data. Use routine dispensing data to identify the highest prescribers – Australia focused on the top 30%.
  2. Build a fair comparison. Compare each GP with similar peers in their area, so the gap feels relevant and hard to dismiss.
  3. Send a personalised letter or report. Include a simple graph showing where the GP sits. Frame it around being an outlier on the high side, not around praise for being average.
  4. Measure and repeat. Track prescribing against a control group or forecast, as the Australian studies did, and keep the feedback going so the change lasts.

Common Mistakes and Limitations

  • Relying on facts alone: GPs already know the risks; information without comparison rarely changes behaviour.
  • Congratulating instead of comparing: praise for being average motivates less than learning you are a high outlier.
  • Expecting identical results everywhere: the UK trial achieved 3.3% versus 12.3% in Australia.
  • Not measuring: without a control group or forecast, it is hard to tell what the intervention achieved.

Related reading: how the Choosing Wisely campaign tackles low-value care.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does behavioural economics reduce antibiotic over-prescription?

By making each GP’s prescribing visible and comparable with peers. Personalised letters showing GPs where they sit tap into professional identity and loss aversion, which changes behaviour more than education alone.

What were the results of Australia’s peer-comparison letters?

Among the top 30% of prescribers, GPs who received a peer-comparison letter cut their antibiotic scripts by 12.3% over six months – more than three times the effect of educational material alone.

Why do GPs over-prescribe antibiotics?

Many GPs know the risks but assume their own prescribing is similar to their colleagues’. Without seeing the comparison, they have no reason to change.

Can this approach work in Asia-Pacific?

Yes. Any health authority or payer with routine prescribing data and large GP or pharmacist networks can use peer-comparison feedback without new legislation or funding.

Next Steps: Turn Prescribing Data Into Behaviour Change

Australia’s campaign shows that behavioural economics can reduce antibiotic over-prescription: all it took was increasing the visibility of GPs’ prescribing habits for them to question their own practice. As a programme manager, focus on moving away from facts and towards emotion, and ask: how can I make this objective more emotionally tangible, how can I make behaviour more transparent and socially engaging, and how can I make the desired behaviour the simplest option?

Want to design a peer-comparison programme for your health system? Get in touch with DeltaMV’s Healthcare Behavioural Strategy team.

Sources

  1. Australian Centre for Disease Control. (2026). Sixth Australian report on antimicrobial use and resistance in human health (AURA report). https://www.amr.gov.au/sites/default/files/2026-02/sixth-australian-report-on-antimicrobial-use-and-resistance-in-human-health-aura-report_0.pdf
  2. Medical Republic. (2018, July 4). Nudge tactics spark drop in antibiotic scripts. https://www.medicalrepublic.com.au/nudge-tactics-spark-drop-antibiotic-scripts/1953
  3. World Health Organization. (2018). Nudge vs superbugs – features from around the world. https://www.who.int/campaigns/world-amr-awareness-week/2018/features-from-around-the-world/nudge-vs-superbugs
  4. Wu, J., Taylor, D., Ovchinikova, L., Heaney, A., Morgan, T., Dartnell, J., Holbrook, R., Humphreys, L., Weekes, L., & Blogg, S. (2018). Relationship between antimicrobial-resistance programs and antibiotic dispensing for upper respiratory tract infection: An analysis of Australian data between 2004 and 2015. Journal of International Medical Research, 46(4), 1326–1338. https://doi.org/10.1177/0300060517740813

What are you trying to change?

Let's explore the behavioural insight behind it.

Connect with us